Discover Westerleigh: Staten Island's Historic and Leafy Retreat

Nestled on Staten Island's North Shore, Westerleigh is a charming and historically significant neighborhood known for its picturesque, tree-lined streets, well-preserved Victorian architecture, and strong sense of community. Originally founded as a temperance community, Westerleigh retains a unique character and offers a tranquil suburban lifestyle with convenient access to local amenities. If you appreciate history, beautiful architecture, and a peaceful, neighborly atmosphere, Westerleigh is a truly special place to call home.

A History Rooted in Reform and Community Spirit

From Temperance Colony to Treasured Neighborhood: Westerleigh's history is distinctive, originating in the 1870s as a planned community founded by members of the National Temperance Society. The vision was to create a family-oriented, alcohol-free haven, and the neighborhood's original layout and Victorian homes reflect this intentional design. Many of its streets are named after prominent figures in the temperance movement. Over time, while the temperance focus evolved, Westerleigh retained its strong sense of community, architectural integrity, and leafy charm, becoming a treasured residential enclave on Staten Island's North Shore.

A Community that Cherishes its History and Green Spaces

Westerleigh fosters a deep sense of community pride, with residents who actively work to preserve the neighborhood's historic character and beautiful green spaces. The Westerleigh Improvement Society plays a vital role in organizing local events and maintaining the area's unique appeal. The abundance of mature trees and well-tended gardens contributes to the neighborhood's tranquil and picturesque ambiance. Residents enjoy a strong sense of belonging and a shared appreciation for the area's rich history and peaceful environment.

Architectural Grandeur and Victorian Charm

The architectural landscape of Westerleigh is a stunning showcase of Victorian-era homes, many of which have been lovingly preserved over the years. You'll find elegant Queen Annes, charming Stick-style houses, and grand Italianates, all contributing to the neighborhood's distinctive character. These historic homes often feature beautiful details such as wrap-around porches, intricate woodwork, and stained-glass windows. The mature trees that line the streets provide a beautiful canopy, enhancing the overall sense of historic charm and creating a truly unique visual appeal.

Real Estate in Westerleigh: Historic Gems and Timeless Appeal

Real estate in Westerleigh primarily features single-family homes, many of which are historic Victorian properties. The market is competitive, reflecting the neighborhood's unique character and desirability.

Preserved Victorian Homes with Modern Updates

Homes in Westerleigh often boast original architectural details alongside modern renovations, offering a perfect blend of historic charm and contemporary comfort. Many properties feature well-maintained gardens and a sense of timeless elegance. Recent trends (as of July 2025) show median home prices around $680,000, reflecting the neighborhood's unique appeal and historic significance.

Properties for History Lovers and Community Enthusiasts

The residences in Westerleigh appeal to buyers who appreciate the beauty of Victorian architecture and the strong sense of community that defines the neighborhood. It's a place where history and neighborly connections thrive.

Amenities and Connectivity: Tranquil Living with Local Convenience

Experience Historic Charm with Modern Comforts: Westerleigh offers a peaceful residential setting with convenient access to local businesses, parks, and transportation links.

Local Shops and Green Spaces

Westerleigh features a charming main street area with local shops, restaurants, and services that cater to the community. The neighborhood is also home to several parks, including Westerleigh Park, a beautiful green space that hosts community events and provides recreational opportunities. The abundance of mature trees throughout the neighborhood adds to its leafy and serene atmosphere.

Proximity to Parks and Community Resources

Residents enjoy easy access to other nearby parks and green spaces, further enhancing the neighborhood's appeal to nature lovers. The Westerleigh branch of the New York Public Library serves as a valuable community resource.

Excellent Schools Serving the Community

Westerleigh is served by well-regarded public and private schools, making it an attractive location for families with children.

Reliable Transportation Links

Westerleigh offers convenient transportation options. Several bus routes serve the neighborhood, providing connections to the Staten Island Ferry and other parts of the island. Major roadways are also easily accessible.

Westerleigh, Staten Island, offers a truly special opportunity to live in a neighborhood rich in history, architectural beauty, and community spirit. Its tranquil atmosphere and unique character make it a captivating and distinctive place to call home.

HOA: No

55+ Community: No