Tottenville, Staten Island, NY

Explore Tottenville: Staten Island's Historic South End

Nestled at the southernmost tip of Staten Island, Tottenville offers a unique blend of rich history, maritime charm, and a close-knit community spirit. Known for its Victorian architecture, waterfront access along the Arthur Kill, and a relaxed pace of life, this neighborhood provides a distinct character that feels a world away from the city.

If you're seeking a community with a strong sense of its past, beautiful waterfront views, and a welcoming atmosphere, Tottenville is a captivating place to call home.

A Legacy of Maritime Trade and Independence

From Coastal Village to Island's End: Tottenville's history is deeply intertwined with its strategic location at the confluence of the Arthur Kill and Raritan Bay. Originally settled in the late 17th century, it became a significant port for oystering, shipbuilding, and maritime trade.

The neighborhood's name honors Captain Christopher Totten, a prominent local figure. Most notably, Tottenville holds deep historical significance as the site of the Conference House, where the only attempt at a peaceful resolution to the American Revolution was made in 1776 between British Admiral Lord Howe and American representatives including Benjamin Franklin. Today, this heritage is palpable in the neighborhood's landmarked streets and enduring connection to the sea.

A Community that Cherishes its Heritage and Waterfront

Tottenville fosters a strong sense of community pride. Residents are actively involved in preserving landmarks and celebrating the neighborhood's unique identity.

• Maritime Lifestyle: The waterfront remains a hub for boating and fishing, with local marinas like the Tottenville Marina providing a base for nautical enthusiasts.

• Events: Annual traditions like Tottenville Day and seasonal festivals at Conference House Park showcase the neighborhood's spirit and history, drawing families from all over the South Shore.

Architectural Charm Reflecting Centuries of History

The architectural landscape of Tottenville is a delightful "outdoor museum." You'll find:

• Victorian Splendor: The neighborhood is famous for its large, wrap-around porch Victorians and Second Empire-style manors, particularly along Bentley Street.

• Colonial Roots: Scattered throughout are some of the oldest structures in the city, alongside charming 1920s bungalows and modern detached homes.

• Preservation: The Tottenville Historical Society works tirelessly to document and preserve these structures, ensuring that new developments respect the neighborhood's historic skyline.

Real Estate in Tottenville: 2026 Market Insights

Real estate in Tottenville offers a range of properties, from historic manors to contemporary waterfront residences.

• Market Trends (Early 2026): As of January 2026, Tottenville remains one of the more expensive and desirable South Shore markets. The median sale price is approximately $1,240,000, reflecting a significant year-over-year increase as buyers seek the privacy and historic character that define the area.

• Inventory: Supply remains tight, with many homes being passed down through generations. When properties do hit the market, move-in-ready historic homes command a premium, often selling in approximately 60 days.

• Waterfront Value: Properties with direct views of the Arthur Kill or proximity to Conference House Park are particularly prized for their scenic appeal and long-term value.

Amenities and Connectivity: Coastal Serenity with Local Convenience

Experience historic charm alongside the modern comforts of South Shore living.

Local Businesses and Waterfront Activities

Tottenville features a charming main street area along Main Street and Amboy Road.

• Dining: Local favorites include Angelina’s Kitchen for high-quality Italian and J's On The Bay for a classic hometown diner feel.

• Culture: The H.H. Biddle House within Conference House Park frequently hosts exhibits on local history and the maritime industry.

Proximity to Parks and Natural Beauty

• Conference House Park: Over 260 acres of parkland featuring historic buildings, hiking trails, and a beach with views across the water to Perth Amboy, NJ.

• Lemon Creek Park: A nearby natural preserve ideal for birdwatching and enjoying the quiet marshes of the South Shore.

Excellent Schools

The neighborhood is served by well-regarded institutions, including P.S. 1 (The Tottenville School) and Tottenville High School, the latter being one of the largest and most academically diverse schools in the borough.

Connectivity and Transportation

As the southernmost point of New York City, Tottenville offers several reliable transit options:

• Railway: The Tottenville SIR Station is the southern terminus of the line, offering a guaranteed seat for the 45-minute ride to the St. George Ferry.

• Express Bus: Commuters utilize the SIM2 and SIM26 for direct service into Midtown and Lower Manhattan.

• Driving: The Outerbridge Crossing is just minutes away, providing an immediate gateway to New Jersey for commuters and travelers.

At a Glance:

• HOA: No

• 55+ Community: No

• Unique Feature: Home to the only attempted peace conference of the American Revolution.

• Vibe: Maritime, Historic, and Peaceful.

Tottenville offers a truly special opportunity to live in a community rich in history and surrounded by natural beauty. Its unique character and waterfront charm make it an exceptionally distinctive place to call home.