Smithtown

Experience Classic Long Island Charm in Smithtown, NY

Smithtown, a historic and vibrant town located in the heart of Long Island, offers an exceptional blend of suburban comfort, natural beauty, and a rich historical legacy. Known for its excellent schools, diverse recreational opportunities, and a strong sense of community, Smithtown is a highly desirable destination for families and individuals seeking a well-rounded Long Island lifestyle.

A Legacy of Horses and Heritage

Smithtown's history dates back to the 17th century, when Richard Smith was granted a large tract of land by the colonial governor, famously riding a bull to mark its boundaries. This legendary ride is commemorated by the iconic "Whisper" statue of a bull and rider at the town's center. Today, Smithtown embraces its heritage while thriving as a modern community. It boasts a welcoming atmosphere and active residents who participate in various local events, fostering a strong sense of pride and connection.

Picturesque Homes and Varied Architecture

The residential landscape of Smithtown is diverse and appealing, featuring a wide array of single-family homes that showcase classic Long Island architectural styles. You'll find charming Colonials, spacious Capes, modern ranches, and elegant Tudors, often set on generous lots with mature trees and well-manicured lawns. This variety ensures there's a home to suit different tastes and needs, all contributing to the town's overall attractive and inviting aesthetic.

Real Estate in Smithtown: A Balanced Market

The real estate market in Smithtown is dynamic. As of June 2025, the median listing home price in Smithtown was approximately $819,500, with the median sold home price around $887,500. Homes in Smithtown sold for 5.92% above asking price on average in June 2025. The market is currently described as a buyer's market, meaning that the supply of homes is greater than the demand. Homes typically spend about 33 days on the market. Whether you're seeking a family home in a great school district or a well-connected suburban base, Smithtown offers compelling real estate opportunities.

Amenities and Connectivity: A Fulfilled Lifestyle

Smithtown's central location in Suffolk County provides residents with excellent access to a wide array of amenities, natural attractions, and efficient transportation links.

Vibrant Downtown and Shopping: Smithtown's downtown area is a lively hub, offering an eclectic mix of local shops, essential services, and a diverse culinary scene with numerous popular restaurants. For more extensive retail therapy, residents have easy access to larger shopping centers in neighboring Commack.

Embrace the Outdoors: Smithtown is a haven for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts. Caleb Smith State Park Preserve is a true gem, offering 543 acres of diverse habitats, well-maintained hiking trails, tranquil ponds, a nature museum, and opportunities for fly fishing. Blydenburgh County Park, located at the headwaters of the Nissequogue River, features miles of trails, a beautiful lake for fishing, and a historic farm. Sunken Meadow State Park offers breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound, sandy beaches, and a three-mile boardwalk. Additionally, the Nissequogue River is popular for kayaking and canoeing.

Exceptional Education: Families are consistently drawn to Smithtown for its highly-rated public school system, the Smithtown Central School District. The district is known for its strong academic programs, dedicated educators, and a wide range of extracurricular activities, providing a supportive and enriching environment for student development. Smithtown High School East and Smithtown High School West consistently receive strong ratings.

Seamless Commuting: Smithtown offers excellent connectivity for commuters. Its location provides easy access to major Long Island roadways, including the Long Island Expressway (I-495) and Northern State Parkway, facilitating travel across the island. The Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) station in Smithtown provides direct train service to Manhattan (approximately 1 hour 19 minutes to Penn Station), making daily commutes and city excursions highly convenient.

Smithtown, Long Island, NY, truly offers a classic suburban experience with an abundance of natural beauty, a vibrant community, and excellent amenities. Its desirable homes, top-tier schools, and a plethora of recreational and commercial offerings make it a truly attractive and well-rounded place to call home.

HOA: Yes (While many single-family homes do not have a neighborhood-wide HOA, there are specific condominium and gated communities within Smithtown that do have HOAs, such as Hidden Pond and Stonebridge.)

55+ Community: Yes (There are 55+ communities and senior living options available in Smithtown, including The Preserve at Smithtown and Country Pointe Woods Smithtown.)