Welcome to Randall Manor: Staten Island's North Shore Gem

Nestled on Staten Island's North Shore, Randall Manor is a prestigious and verdant neighborhood that offers an ideal blend of historic charm, tranquil living, and unparalleled convenience. Known for its lush, tree-lined streets and classic architecture, this community provides a quiet suburban retreat with quick access to the cultural heart of the island and a seamless commute to Manhattan. If you're seeking a distinguished neighborhood with a strong sense of community and timeless appeal, Randall Manor is an exceptional place to call home.

A Legacy of Land and Philanthropy

From Snug Harbor to Suburban Enclave: The history of Randall Manor is deeply connected to its neighbor, the historic Sailors' Snug Harbor. The neighborhood is named for Captain Robert Richard Randall, the founder of the original charitable home for retired sailors. The land, once part of the expansive Snug Harbor property, was developed in the early 20th century, creating a residential community that retains its historic elegance. Unlike other affluent areas on the island's central hills, Randall Manor is a more level, verdant enclave that has been a highly desirable address for generations.

A Community that Values Character and Quiet

Randall Manor is renowned for its peaceful, friendly atmosphere and strong community ties. The neighborhood's streets are exceptionally quiet, with minimal traffic, fostering a sense of safety and neighborliness. Residents take pride in their well-maintained homes and lush gardens, contributing to the area's beautiful, old-world charm. The community is a mix of long-time residents and new families, creating a stable and welcoming environment that is perfect for putting down roots.

Architectural Splendor and Timeless Design

The architectural landscape of Randall Manor is a beautiful tapestry of classic styles. You'll find a wide variety of well-preserved homes, many built before the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge opened in 1964. These include stately Tudors, classic Colonials, elegant Victorians, and even some Spanish Colonial and Federal-style homes. This architectural diversity, combined with the mature trees and meticulous landscaping, creates a unique and captivating visual appeal that is a hallmark of the neighborhood.

Real Estate in Randall Manor: Classic Homes and Competitive Options

Real estate in Randall Manor is a mix of classic detached single-family homes, with a limited number of co-ops and condos available. The market is competitive, reflecting the neighborhood's prestige and desirable location.

Spacious Residences with Historic Charm

Homes in Randall Manor often feature generous living spaces, blending original details with modern updates. Many properties are set on well-sized lots with private driveways and beautiful yards. Recent trends (as of June 2025) show median home prices around $897,000, and homes tend to sell quickly, underscoring the neighborhood's strong appeal and value.

Properties for Families and Commuters Seeking Elegance

The residences in Randall Manor appeal to buyers who desire a tranquil, elegant lifestyle with easy access to city life. It is a perfect choice for families seeking top-tier schools and a safe environment, as well as professionals who value a quick and convenient commute.

Amenities and Connectivity: Seclusion with Unbeatable Access

Experience Suburban Life with Unmatched Urban Convenience: Randall Manor offers a serene residential setting while providing unmatched access to a variety of local businesses, cultural attractions, and excellent transportation links.

A Thriving Local Scene and Cultural Hotspots

Randall Manor is bordered by commercial corridors on Forest, Castleton, and Henderson Avenues, offering residents a variety of shops, restaurants, and cafes. A major draw is the neighborhood's immediate proximity to the Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden, a renowned cultural campus that includes museums, a children's museum, and beautiful gardens, providing endless opportunities for art, education, and recreation. Allison Pond Park, a nine-acre green space with a walking path, is also located within the neighborhood.

Proximity to Parks and Green Spaces

Beyond Snug Harbor, Randall Manor is also conveniently located near Silver Lake Park, a large green haven with a golf course, dog run, and walking paths. The abundance of green space gives residents a tranquil, country-like feel within the city.

Excellent Schools and Academic Resources

Families in Randall Manor are served by highly-rated public schools, including PS 45, IS 61, and Curtis High School, as well as a variety of private and parochial school options nearby.

Exceptional Accessibility

Randall Manor's location on the North Shore gives it a distinct advantage for commuters. The neighborhood is just a short drive or bus ride away from the St. George Ferry Terminal, providing a free and scenic commute to Manhattan. Numerous local and express bus routes crisscross the area, further enhancing its connectivity to all parts of the island and beyond.

Randall Manor, Staten Island, offers a truly special opportunity to experience an elegant, community-rich, and incredibly well-connected lifestyle. Its historic charm, beautiful homes, and prime location make it an exceptionally desirable and engaging place to call home.

HOA: No

55+ Community: No