Randall Manor, Staten Island, NY
Welcome to Randall Manor: Staten Island's North Shore Gem
Nestled on Staten Island's North Shore, Randall Manor is a prestigious and verdant neighborhood that offers an ideal blend of historic charm, tranquil living, and unparalleled convenience. Known for its lush, tree-lined streets and classic architecture, this community provides a quiet suburban retreat with quick access to the cultural heart of the island and a seamless commute to Manhattan.
If you're seeking a distinguished neighborhood with a strong sense of community and timeless appeal, Randall Manor is an exceptional place to call home.
A Legacy of Land and Philanthropy
From Snug Harbor to Suburban Enclave: The history of Randall Manor is deeply connected to its neighbor, the historic Sailors' Snug Harbor. The neighborhood is named for Captain Robert Richard Randall, the founder of the original charitable home for retired sailors.
The land, once part of the expansive Snug Harbor property, was developed in the early 20th century, creating a residential community that retains its historic elegance. Unlike other affluent areas on the island's central hills, Randall Manor is a more level, verdant enclave that has been a highly desirable address for generations.
A Community that Values Character and Quiet
Randall Manor is renowned for its peaceful, friendly atmosphere and strong community ties. The neighborhood's streets are exceptionally quiet, with minimal traffic, fostering a sense of safety and neighborliness. Residents take pride in their well-maintained homes and lush gardens, contributing to the area's beautiful, old-world charm.
The community is a mix of long-time residents and new families, creating a stable and welcoming environment. In early 2026, the city announced the expansion of Goodhue Park, a project that will further enhance the green footprint of the Randall Manor and New Brighton border.
Architectural Splendor and Timeless Design
The architectural landscape of Randall Manor is a beautiful tapestry of classic styles:
Classic Styles: You'll find a wide variety of well-preserved homes, including stately Tudors, classic Colonials, and elegant Victorians.
Rare Designs: The neighborhood also features unique Spanish Colonial and Federal-style homes, a rarity in the five boroughs.
Pre-War Integrity: Most development was completed before the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge opened in 1964, meaning the neighborhood has largely avoided the "teardown" trends of other areas, preserving its 1920s and 30s suburban planning.
Real Estate in Randall Manor: 2026 Market Insights
Real estate in Randall Manor is highly sought after, known for its stability and the quality of its detached single-family housing stock.
Pricing Trends: As of early 2026, the market in Randall Manor remains robust. The median sale price for homes is approximately $925,000, reflecting a significant 37% year-over-year increase as buyers flee denser urban areas for the neighborhood's suburban elegance.
Market Activity: Homes typically spend an average of 42 days on the market, much faster than the borough average.
High-End Properties: Large, renovated estates in the heart of the "Manor" frequently command prices between $1.1 million and $1.5 million, while well-maintained starter homes in the periphery can be found in the $700,000s.
Amenities and Connectivity: Seclusion with Unbeatable Access
Experience suburban life with the best cultural and transit links on the North Shore.
A Thriving Local Scene and Cultural Hotspots
Randall Manor is bordered by commercial corridors on Forest, Castleton, and Henderson Avenues.
Dining: Local favorites include the diverse offerings along Forest Avenue, and the nearby St. George waterfront features Enoteca Maria, famous for its rotating international "Nonnas."
Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden: This 83-acre campus is the neighborhood's "backyard." Highlights include the Chinese Scholar’s Garden, the Newhouse Center for Contemporary Art, and a steady calendar of 2026 events like the Glass House Tours and specialized horticulture workshops.
Proximity to Parks and Green Spaces
Allison Pond Park: A nine-acre green space within the neighborhood featuring a serene pond, walking paths, and a popular dog run.
Silver Lake Park: Located just south, this vast park offers a golf course, tennis courts, and walking trails around a picturesque reservoir.
Excellent Schools
Families in Randall Manor are served by some of the borough's most respected public institutions:
P.S. 45 The John Tyler School: Known for its strong parental involvement and academic performance.
Curtis High School: A historic landmark school offering prestigious IB and nursing programs.
Staten Island Technical High School: Located a short drive away, it is consistently ranked as one of the top high schools in New York State.
Exceptional Accessibility
Randall Manor's location gives it a distinct advantage for those working in the city:
Ferry Access: Just a 5-10 minute bus or car ride to the Staten Island Ferry Terminal, offering a free, scenic 25-minute trip to Lower Manhattan.
Bus Service: The S48 and S98 run frequently along Forest Avenue, and the SIM30 express bus provides a direct, comfortable coach ride into Manhattan.
At a Glance:
HOA: No
55+ Community: No
2026 Median Price: ~$925,000
Vibe: Historic, Philanthropic, and Distinguished.
Randall Manor offers a truly special opportunity to experience an elegant, community-rich, and incredibly well-connected lifestyle. Its historic charm and prime location make it an exceptionally engaging place to call home.
