Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, NY
Discover Prince’s Bay: Staten Island's Waterfront Gem
Nestled on the southernmost shore of Staten Island, Prince’s Bay offers a unique coastal charm defined by its breathtaking waterfront views and deep-rooted maritime history. This picturesque neighborhood boasts a tranquil atmosphere, a strong sense of community, and a delightful blend of historic landmarks and modern conveniences.
If you're seeking a serene, seaside setting with a close-knit feel and stunning natural beauty, Prince’s Bay presents an idyllic place to call home.
A History Rooted in the Sea and Community
From Oyster Beds to Waterfront Haven: In the 19th century, Prince’s Bay was a thriving hub for the oyster industry, once so productive that its harvests were celebrated in the finest restaurants of Manhattan. The neighborhood is named after Christopher Prince, a prominent local oysterman and landowner.
As the industry faded, the area evolved into a residential sanctuary prized for its waterfront access. Today, the maritime character remains alive through landmarks like the Prince’s Bay Lighthouse (also known as the John Cardinal O'Connor Lighthouse). Built in 1864, it sits atop the highest ocean-facing bluffs in New York State. The surrounding Mount Loretto site, once the largest orphanage in the state, adds a layer of cultural and historical depth to the landscape.
A Community that Cherishes its Coastal Identity
Prince’s Bay fosters a resilient and proud community. Residents share a deep appreciation for the quiet, salt-air environment and actively participate in preserving the area’s unique character. Whether it's morning strolls along the bluffs or sunset gatherings at local yacht clubs, there is a palpable sense of connection among those who call this coastal enclave home.
Architectural Diversity with a Seaside Flair
The architectural landscape of Prince’s Bay is a diverse mix that reflects over a century of development:
Historic Treasures: You will find well-preserved Victorian and Greek Revival homes, including the landmarked Seguine Mansion, which offers a glimpse into 19th-century luxury.
Modern Luxury: The neighborhood features contemporary custom-built estates and newer developments, many of which are designed with expansive decks and large windows to maximize views of Raritan Bay.
Marinas and Boat Clubs: The presence of the Princess Bay Boatmen's Association and the proximity to the Lemon Creek Marina emphasize the neighborhood's status as a premier location for boating enthusiasts.
Real Estate in Prince’s Bay: Waterfront Properties and Suburban Comfort
Real estate in Prince’s Bay caters to a range of lifestyles, from direct waterfront living to quiet suburban streets.
Market Insights (2025-2026): As of early 2026, Prince’s Bay continues to be a premium market on the South Shore. Median home sale prices are approximately $1,097,000, reflecting a nearly 24% year-over-year increase as buyers seek the privacy and space this neighborhood affords.
Diverse Options: While older, character-filled bungalows still exist, the trend is toward larger, multi-million dollar detached homes. Many properties feature private docks or are within walking distance of the shore.
Amenities and Connectivity: Seaside Serenity with Modern Conveniences
Experience waterfront living with easy access to modern lifestyle needs:
A Thriving Local Scene and Nearby Hotspots
The neighborhood features a charming mix of local eateries and retail:
Dining: Enjoy fresh catches at Cole’s Dockside or high-end Italian fare along the Amboy Road corridor.
Shopping: Residents are a short drive from the South Shore Commons and the Staten Island Mall for a full range of retail and services.
Proximity to Parks and Natural Beauty
The greatest amenity of Prince’s Bay is its vast protected land:
Mount Loretto Unique Area: Over 200 acres of grasslands, wetlands, and shoreline—perfect for birdwatching and hiking.
Lemon Creek Park: A popular spot for fishing, birding, and launching kayaks, this park is home to a rare purple martin colony and a thriving nature center.
Connectivity and Transportation
For a waterfront community, Prince’s Bay is remarkably accessible:
Rail: The Prince’s Bay SIR Station provides a reliable 35-minute link to the Staten Island Ferry.
Express Bus: Commuters benefit from the SIM25 Express Bus, which provides direct service into Midtown Manhattan in approximately 70 minutes.
Road: Access to the West Shore Expressway and Outerbridge Crossing is just minutes away, providing a quick gateway to New Jersey and points west.
At a Glance:
HOA: Yes (Primarily in newer communities/private developments)
55+ Community: No
Unique Feature: Highest ocean-facing bluffs in New York State (75 ft).
Vibe: Coastal, Historical, and Upscale.
Prince’s Bay offers a truly special opportunity to embrace a tranquil, coastal lifestyle without leaving New York City. Its stunning views and relaxed atmosphere make it an exceptionally unique place to call home.
