Discover Prince’s Bay: Staten Island's Waterfront Gem

Nestled on the southernmost shore of Staten Island, Prince’s Bay offers a unique coastal charm with breathtaking waterfront views and a rich maritime history. This picturesque neighborhood boasts a tranquil atmosphere, a strong sense of community, and a delightful blend of historic landmarks and modern conveniences. If you're seeking a serene, seaside setting with a close-knit feel and stunning natural beauty, Prince’s Bay presents an idyllic place to call home.

A History Rooted in the Sea and Community

From Oyster Beds to Waterfront Haven: Prince’s Bay’s history is intrinsically linked to its location on Raritan Bay. Once a thriving hub for oyster harvesting in the 19th century, the area gradually evolved into a residential community prized for its waterfront access and scenic vistas. The neighborhood is named after Christopher Prince, a prominent local oysterman. Today, Prince’s Bay retains its maritime character, with landmarks like the historic Prince’s Bay Lighthouse at the southern tip of the Mount Loretto Unique Area serving as enduring reminders of its past. The Mount Loretto site itself, with its rich history as a mission and school, adds another layer of historical significance to the area.

A Community that Cherishes its Coastal Identity

Prince’s Bay fosters a strong sense of community among its residents, who share a deep appreciation for its tranquil, coastal environment. The neighborhood is known for its friendly atmosphere and local events that often revolve around its waterfront location. Residents take pride in preserving the area's natural beauty and its unique character. Whether strolling along the shore or participating in community gatherings, there's a palpable sense of connection and pride in calling Prince’s Bay home.

Architectural Diversity with a Seaside Flair

The architectural landscape of Prince’s Bay is a diverse mix of styles, reflecting its growth over time. You'll find everything from charming bungalows and well-maintained older homes to newer, contemporary constructions, many offering stunning views of Raritan Bay. The presence of boat clubs, marinas, and waterfront properties further enhances the neighborhood's coastal appeal. Properties often feature spacious yards and a relaxed, seaside aesthetic that complements the natural surroundings.

Real Estate in Prince’s Bay: Waterfront Properties and Suburban Comfort

Real estate in Prince’s Bay offers a variety of options, from homes with direct waterfront access to comfortable suburban residences. The market caters to those seeking a coastal lifestyle or a peaceful community setting.

Scenic Properties and Suburban Charm

Homes in Prince’s Bay offer a range of living spaces, with many boasting water views and features designed to embrace the coastal environment. You'll find properties with private docks, decks perfect for enjoying sunsets, and a relaxed, beach-inspired vibe. The neighborhood also offers more traditional suburban homes with well-maintained yards. Recent trends (as of May 2025) show median home prices reflecting its waterfront appeal and desirable location, generally ranging from the mid-$600,000s upwards.

Properties for Those Seeking a Coastal or Family-Friendly Lifestyle

The residences in Prince’s Bay appeal to buyers who desire a tranquil, community-oriented neighborhood with a strong connection to the water. Whether it's a waterfront retreat or a comfortable family home, the emphasis is on enjoying the relaxed pace of life and the natural beauty of the area.

Amenities and Connectivity: Seaside Serenity with Modern Conveniences

Experience Waterfront Living with Easy Access: Prince’s Bay offers a serene, coastal lifestyle while providing convenient access to local amenities, dining options, and transportation links.

A Thriving Local Scene and Nearby Hotspots

Prince’s Bay boasts its own local shops and eateries, creating a convenient and charming atmosphere. Nearby commercial areas along Amboy Road offer a wider variety of shopping and dining options. Residents also enjoy close proximity to the recreational amenities of the South Shore, including beaches and parks.

Proximity to Parks and Natural Beauty

A significant draw of Prince’s Bay is its access to stunning natural areas. The Mount Loretto Unique Area provides miles of shoreline, walking trails, and opportunities for birdwatching and enjoying the outdoors. Lemon Creek Park, with its marina and nature center, is also a popular local spot for recreation and relaxation.

Excellent Schools and Community Resources

Families in Prince’s Bay are served by the District 31 schools, with a number of public and private school options in the vicinity. The neighborhood also benefits from local community organizations and resources.

Strong Community Spirit and Local Traditions

Prince’s Bay is known for its strong sense of community and local traditions, often centered around its maritime heritage. Residents actively participate in neighborhood events and take pride in their unique coastal identity.

Connectivity and Transportation

Prince’s Bay offers good transportation options for a waterfront community. The Prince’s Bay station on the Staten Island Railway provides a direct link to the St. George Ferry Terminal and other parts of the island. Several local bus routes also serve the area, making it relatively easy to get around. Major roadways are also accessible for those who prefer to drive.

Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, offers a truly special opportunity to embrace a tranquil, coastal lifestyle with a strong sense of community and rich history. Its stunning waterfront views and relaxed atmosphere make it an exceptionally desirable and unique place to call home.

HOA: Yes (Similar to Pleasant Plains, Prince's Bay is a larger neighborhood, and while many individual older homes may not have an HOA, newer developments and some communities within Prince's Bay do have homeowners' associations.)

55+ Community: No