East Islip

Experience Waterfront Charm and Strong Community in East Islip, Long Island, NY

East Islip, a picturesque hamlet nestled on Long Island's South Shore, offers an idyllic blend of peaceful suburban living and vibrant community spirit, all against a backdrop of stunning waterfront beauty. Once home to grand estates, today's East Islip is the epitome of comfortable suburbia, where life is defined by its connection to the Great South Bay and a deep sense of belonging among its residents.

A Legacy of Estates and a Thriving Community Today

East Islip's history stretches back to the 17th century, when it was part of a vast land purchase by William Nicoll. Later, it became a favored location for the nation's wealthiest families, with grand estates dotting the landscape. While those large estates have largely given way to more modern, yet still affluent communities, East Islip has beautifully preserved its sense of exclusivity and community. Residents here truly love where they live, often choosing to "house-hop" within the hamlet as their needs change, rather than leaving altogether. This dedication to the community is evident in the numerous local events and friendly atmosphere.

Diverse Homes and Direct Water Access

The residential character of East Islip is appealing and varied. You'll find a mix of single-family homes, ranging from charming classic styles to more contemporary designs. Many properties boast well-maintained yards, and a significant draw is the abundance of gorgeous waterfront homes with private or association docking privileges. For water lovers, East Islip offers unparalleled access to the Great South Bay, making it a boater's paradise.

Real Estate in East Islip: A Competitive and Desirable Market

The real estate market in East Islip is active and competitive, reflecting its strong appeal. As of June 2025, the median sale price for homes in East Islip was approximately $852,500, showing a significant increase of nearly 23% compared to last year. Homes typically sell after about 43 days on the market, indicating strong buyer interest. Properties, especially those with waterfront access, are highly sought after, with many selling above asking price. Whether you're dreaming of a home with a private dock or a peaceful suburban retreat, East Islip offers compelling real estate opportunities.

Amenities and Connectivity: Recreation and Convenience by the Bay

East Islip's prime South Shore location provides residents with excellent access to a wealth of amenities, natural beauty, and efficient transportation links.

Embrace the Water and Outdoors: Life in East Islip is synonymous with outdoor recreation. The East Islip Marina Park offers a marina, a small town beach, and sports fields. Other marinas are dotted along the local creeks and lakes, providing endless opportunities for boating, fishing, and kayaking. Brookwood Hall Park, a peaceful spot on one of these lakes, features walking paths, a playground, tennis courts, and an indoor recreation center. The South Shore Nature Center boasts 200 acres of hiking trails, and the expansive Heckscher State Park is nearby, offering even more hiking, a campground, and boat launches. For those without a private boat, Fire Island ferry terminals in nearby Bay Shore and Sayville provide easy access to the pristine ocean beaches, shops, and restaurants of Fire Island.

Local Conveniences and Growing Main Street: East Islip offers a convenient array of local businesses, shops, restaurants, and coffee shops. While it retains its charming, almost rural feel, its Main Street (Montauk Highway) is growing and improving. For more extensive shopping and dining, the vibrant downtowns of Islip Town and Sayville are just a short drive away.

Exceptional Education: Families are consistently drawn to East Islip for its highly-regarded public school system, the East Islip Union Free School District. The district includes several elementary schools (Connetquot, John F. Kennedy, Ruth C. Kinney, and Timber Point) and East Islip Middle School and High School. The schools are known for their strong academic programs and dedicated educators, providing a supportive and enriching environment for student development. St. Mary School also offers a private elementary and middle school option.

Commuting with Ease: East Islip offers convenient access to major Long Island roadways, including Sunrise Highway and the Southern State Parkway, facilitating travel across the island. While East Islip does not have its own LIRR station, residents can easily access nearby stations in Great River, Islip, or Bay Shore, which provide direct train service to Manhattan (Penn Station and Grand Central). Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) is also a short drive away, offering a convenient option for air travel.

East Islip, Long Island, NY, truly offers an outstanding blend of coastal charm, a strong and engaging community, top-tier schools, and abundant recreational opportunities. Its desirable homes, peaceful atmosphere, and easy access to both natural beauty and urban centers make it a truly attractive and well-rounded place to call home.

HOA: Yes (While many traditional single-family homes do not have a neighborhood-wide HOA, there are specific gated, luxury waterfront communities like "The Moorings" and other condominium or 55+ developments in East Islip and the surrounding areas that do have their own HOAs.)

55+ Community: Yes (There are specific 55+ communities and senior living options available in or very near East Islip, such as East Islip Gardens and other complexes in the broader Islip area.)