Welcome to Bay Terrace: Staten Island's East Shore Gem

Nestled along the scenic East Shore of Staten Island, Bay Terrace is a charming and well-established neighborhood that offers an ideal blend of suburban tranquility, waterfront beauty, and convenient amenities. Known for its picturesque views of the Raritan Bay and the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, this community provides a peaceful and family-friendly environment. If you're seeking a quiet retreat with a strong sense of community and excellent access to both nature and city life, Bay Terrace is a wonderful place to call home.

A History of Waterfront Transformation

From Undeveloped Land to Residential Haven: The history of Bay Terrace is a story of transformation. While the area was largely undeveloped for much of its past, residential development began in earnest in the late 1950s. The neighborhood's name, Bay Terrace, is a perfect reflection of its geography—a ramp-like terrain that gently slopes down to the Lower New York Bay. This development created a desirable residential community that drew families, many from Brooklyn, who were seeking a quieter lifestyle and beautiful surroundings.

A Community that Values Peace and Connection

Bay Terrace fosters a strong sense of community, with residents who appreciate the neighborhood's quiet streets and peaceful atmosphere. The area is known for its friendly and welcoming vibe, where neighbors often come together for local events and initiatives. Community pride is evident in the well-maintained homes and properties, contributing to the neighborhood's overall suburban charm. The waterfront provides a natural gathering place for residents to enjoy leisurely walks and scenic views.

Architectural Diversity and Coastal Charm

The architectural landscape of Bay Terrace is a diverse mix of styles that reflects its post-war development. You'll find a variety of single-family homes, townhouses, and condominiums, with styles ranging from traditional colonials and ranches to more modern designs. Many properties are well-maintained and feature inviting front lawns, adding to the neighborhood's appeal. This blend of styles and housing types ensures there's a home to suit every taste, from cozy family residences to more contemporary living arrangements.

Real Estate in Bay Terrace: Diverse Homes and Desirable Properties

Real estate in Bay Terrace is highly sought after, offering a range of housing options that appeal to various preferences and budgets. The market is competitive, reflecting the neighborhood's excellent reputation and prime location.

Character-Filled and Accessible Properties

Homes in Bay Terrace often provide comfortable and spacious living areas. Many properties offer the benefit of being close to the water, providing beautiful views and a unique coastal feel. Recent trends (as of June 2025) show median home prices around $720,000, reflecting the neighborhood's value and desirability.

Properties for Families and Nature Lovers

The residences in Bay Terrace appeal to buyers who desire a tranquil, family-friendly community with access to natural beauty. It is an excellent choice for those seeking a suburban lifestyle with the added benefit of being near the waterfront and a variety of parks.

Amenities and Connectivity: Seclusion with Urban Access

Experience Suburban Life with Unmatched Convenience: Bay Terrace offers a peaceful residential setting while providing convenient access to a variety of local businesses, recreational opportunities, and excellent transportation links.

A Thriving Local Scene and Natural Hotspots

Bay Terrace residents have easy access to a variety of shops and restaurants along nearby Hylan Boulevard and Amboy Road. A major draw is the neighborhood's immediate proximity to Great Kills Park, a vast expanse of green space with beaches, bike paths, walking trails, and a marina. This provides endless opportunities for outdoor activities and enjoying the natural beauty of the area.

Proximity to Parks and Green Spaces

Beyond Great Kills Park, residents are close to other local parks and the Raritan Bay waterfront. This abundance of green space gives the neighborhood a serene, country-like feel within the city.

Excellent Schools and Academic Resources

Families in Bay Terrace are served by highly-rated public schools, including The Barbara Esselborn School (P.S. 53) and Myra S. Barnes School (P.S. 50), making it an attractive location for those with children.

Exceptional Accessibility

Bay Terrace enjoys excellent transportation options. The Bay Terrace station on the Staten Island Railway provides a direct link to the St. George Ferry Terminal. Additionally, numerous local and express bus routes serve the area, making commutes to Brooklyn and Manhattan, as well as travel throughout the island, convenient and manageable.

Bay Terrace, Staten Island, offers a truly special opportunity to experience a peaceful, community-rich, and incredibly well-connected lifestyle. Its waterfront beauty, suburban charm, and prime location make it an exceptionally desirable and engaging place to call home.

HOA: Yes (While not all homes in the larger neighborhood of Bay Terrace are part of an HOA, there are several condominium and co-op communities that have their own homeowners' associations, such as Kensington Gardens.)

55+ Community: No