Welcome to Annadale: Staten Island's Premier South Shore Retreat

Located on Staten Island's serene South Shore, Annadale is a well-established and highly sought-after neighborhood that offers an ideal blend of quiet, suburban living with convenient access to both natural beauty and modern amenities. Defined by its well-kept homes, a strong community spirit, and proximity to the Raritan Bay waterfront, Annadale provides a peaceful and family-friendly environment. If you are looking for a beautiful and stable community with excellent schools and a tranquil vibe, Annadale is an exceptional place to call home.

A History Anchored by the Rails

From Seaside Farmland to a Thriving Suburb: Annadale's history dates back to the 1860s, when a newly opened railway stop gave the area its name, reportedly after the wife of the railroad's treasurer, Anna Seguine. This new connection to the rest of the island spurred a transformation from a rural, seaside landscape into a burgeoning residential community. The neighborhood's rich history also includes a unique "Spanish Colony" of immigrants in the early 20th century and, later, the development of the prestigious Southeast Annadale section with its custom mansions along the water's edge, many of which remain among the most prized homes on Staten Island.

A Community that Values Peace and Connection

Annadale is renowned for its quiet streets, safe environment, and a strong sense of community. The neighborhood is a mix of long-time residents and newcomers, all of whom contribute to a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. Tree-lined streets and well-maintained front lawns create a picturesque backdrop for a lifestyle that values neighborly interaction and a slower pace of life. Community pride is evident in local parks and memorials, such as Annadale Green, which commemorates fallen veterans.

Architectural Diversity and Coastal Charm

The visual appeal of Annadale is characterized by its diverse housing stock. The neighborhood features a variety of architectural styles, including classic colonials, ranches, and townhouses. The exclusive Southeast Annadale section is known for its luxurious custom homes and mansions, some with stunning ocean views. Many properties feature spacious yards and beautiful landscaping, adding to the suburban feel. This blend of styles offers something for every taste, from charming older homes with classic details to sleek, modern residences.

Real Estate in Annadale: Diverse Options and Desirable Properties

Real estate in Annadale is highly desirable, offering a range of housing options from single-family homes to townhouses and condos. The market is competitive, reflecting the neighborhood's excellent reputation.

Character-Filled and Accessible Properties

Homes in Annadale often provide comfortable and spacious living, blending original details with contemporary updates. You can find well-appointed homes with gourmet kitchens, hardwood floors, and private backyards perfect for families. The housing market is competitive, with recent trends (as of May 2025) showing median listing prices around $997,000, and a median sold price around $930,000, highlighting the neighborhood's value.

Properties for Families and Suburban Dwellers

Annadale is a prime location for those seeking a family-friendly community with high-quality schools and an abundance of green space. Whether you're looking for a comfortable starter home, a spacious house for a growing family, or a luxurious waterfront estate, Annadale offers a variety of options that cater to a suburban lifestyle.

Amenities and Connectivity: Seclusion with Urban Access

Experience Suburban Life with Modern Conveniences: Annadale offers a peaceful residential setting while providing convenient access to local businesses, dining, and excellent transportation links.

A Thriving Local Scene and Natural Hotspots

The heart of Annadale's commercial scene can be found along Amboy Road, which offers a variety of shops, restaurants, and local services. Residents also benefit from the neighborhood's proximity to beautiful natural attractions. Blue Heron Park Preserve, a 169-acre protected natural area, provides a tranquil escape with walking trails, ponds, and diverse wildlife. For beach lovers, the nearby waterfront and beaches offer opportunities for relaxation and recreation.

Proximity to Green Spaces and Community Hubs

Beyond Blue Heron Park, Annadale is home to smaller neighborhood parks and is well-situated for easy access to the Staten Island Greenbelt. The neighborhood's parks, such as Annadale Green and Bayview Terrace Park, serve as important community hubs for gatherings and outdoor activities.

Excellent Schools and Academic Resources

Annadale is known for its high-quality school system. Families are served by well-regarded public schools such as P.S. 36 and I.S. 7. The neighborhood is also home to private schools like St. Joseph's by the Sea, a Catholic high school with an impressive sports complex, further enhancing its appeal to families.

Exceptional Accessibility

Annadale is well-connected by public transportation, making commutes and travel manageable. The Annadale station on the Staten Island Railway provides a direct link to the St. George Ferry Terminal. Additionally, numerous local and express bus routes serve the area, and major roadways like the Korean War Veterans Expressway offer quick access to the North Shore and beyond.

Annadale, Staten Island, offers a truly special opportunity to experience a peaceful, family-friendly, and community-rich lifestyle. Its stunning natural beauty, high-quality schools, and blend of suburban tranquility and urban access make it an exceptionally desirable and engaging place to call home.

HOA: Yes (While not all homes in the neighborhood have an HOA, some newer developments and exclusive communities within Annadale do.)
55+ Community: No